A surprising number of accountancy relationships sour not because of a single major failure, but because of quietly mismatched expectations that were simply never discussed openly right at the start. One party assumes weekly contact is entirely normal, the other assumes it genuinely isn't needed unless specifically requested. One party expects proactive tax planning to be included as standard, the other views it as a completely separate, chargeable service on top. Setting expectations clearly from day one prevents these frustrating misunderstandings before they ever get the chance to genuinely damage the underlying trust between you.
Define What "Included" Actually Means in Practice
Before signing any engagement letter, get absolute clarity on precisely what's included within the agreed fee and what genuinely isn't covered at all. Does the service cover ad hoc advice given throughout the year, or purely the specific compliance tasks explicitly listed in the contract? Is a certain number of calls or emails genuinely included, with additional support charged separately beyond that? Ambiguity here is genuinely one of the most common sources of billing disputes later on, and it's far easier to clarify everything upfront than to renegotiate later once real frustration has already firmly set in on both sides.
A good way to test this in practice is to ask for two or three worked examples of things that would fall outside the standard fee, based on situations they've genuinely encountered with other clients before. Concrete examples like this are far more revealing than a general description of scope, and they give you a realistic sense of how easily additional charges might actually arise once you're a working client rather than a prospective one.
Agree on Communication Channels and Genuine Frequency
Explicitly discuss exactly how you'll communicate going forward: email, phone calls, a client portal, or perhaps some sensible combination of all three. Agree roughly how often you'll genuinely be in contact beyond the fixed statutory deadlines, whether that's quarterly check-ins, monthly management accounts, or purely reactive support whenever you happen to raise a query yourself. Having this conversation early means neither side is left quietly guessing, and it gives you a genuinely clear benchmark to refer back to later if communication ever starts to feel inconsistent or noticeably inadequate.
It's also worth agreeing what happens outside of normal working hours or during holiday periods, since these gaps often catch business owners off guard. A firm that's upfront about cover arrangements during quieter periods, rather than leaving you to discover the gap unexpectedly, demonstrates a level of planning that tends to carry through into the rest of the relationship as well.
It's a small detail on paper, but it matters a great deal in practice. Many genuine emergencies, an urgent HMRC letter, or a supplier threatening legal action over an unpaid invoice, don't politely wait for normal office hours, and knowing in advance exactly how your firm handles these moments removes one more source of stress from an already difficult situation.
Clarify Precisely Who You'll Actually Deal With
Ask specifically who your main point of contact will genuinely be on a day-to-day basis, and whether that person is actually different from whoever you originally dealt with during the initial sales process. Understanding the real structure of your support, whether it's a single dedicated contact or a wider shared team, sets genuinely realistic expectations about consistency going forward. This is particularly relevant for firms offering a dedicated relationship manager as part of their core model, since it changes how continuity actually works in practice compared with a firm relying on a shared support desk instead.
If a shared team model is genuinely the norm at a particular firm, ask how that team stays coordinated so you're not left repeating yourself to whoever happens to answer on a given day. A well-run shared model can still work perfectly well, but only if the underlying systems for logging and sharing client context are genuinely robust rather than left to informal memory between colleagues.
Set Clear Expectations Around Turnaround Times
Agree genuinely realistic turnaround times for common types of request: how long does a typical query actually take to answer properly, how far in advance should you send documents ahead of a looming deadline, and what's the real process if something is genuinely urgent and can't wait. Having these clear benchmarks established early gives both sides a genuinely shared understanding to work from, and it gives you legitimate grounds to raise concerns later if response times start noticeably slipping without any real explanation offered.
Discuss Openly How Problems Will Be Handled
No relationship is ever entirely free of occasional hiccups, so it's genuinely worth discussing early on how issues will actually be managed whenever they do arise. Will you be told proactively the moment a mistake is identified internally? Is there a genuinely clear process for raising a concern and getting it properly addressed in a reasonable time? Firms confident in their own processes are usually genuinely happy to walk through this openly with you, and their answer tells you a great deal about how transparent the relationship will realistically be over time.
It's also worth asking what happens if you're simply unhappy with something, even if it doesn't amount to a clear-cut mistake on their part. A firm with a genuine, structured way of hearing and acting on feedback, rather than treating every conversation as informal and easily forgotten, is far more likely to keep improving the relationship steadily over the years you work together.
These early conversations set a tone that carries forward for years, so it's worth taking the time to have them properly rather than rushing through onboarding purely to get compliance work underway as quickly as possible.
- Clarify exactly what's genuinely included in your agreed fee upfront
- Agree communication channels and a realistic, sustainable contact frequency
- Confirm precisely who your day-to-day contact will actually be
- Set clear, specific turnaround time expectations for common requests
Revisit Expectations as Your Business Genuinely Grows
Expectations set right at the very start of a relationship won't necessarily remain right forever as circumstances change. As your business grows in complexity or turnover over time, it's genuinely worth revisiting the original agreement and discussing openly whether the level of service still actually matches your evolving needs. Businesses scaling towards a more comprehensive virtual finance director service often find this is precisely the natural point at which the original, lighter-touch arrangement genuinely needs a deliberate, considered upgrade.
Put the Key Agreements in Writing
Verbal agreements are all too easily forgotten or remembered quite differently by each side several months later. Wherever genuinely possible, confirm important expectations properly in writing, whether that's a short follow-up email sent after a meeting or specific terms included directly within the engagement letter itself. This simple, disciplined habit creates a genuinely clear reference point that protects both you and your accountant from honest misunderstandings further down the line.
The Bottom Line
Setting clear expectations with your local accountant from day one isn't about being overly formal or unduly suspicious of them, it's genuinely about giving the relationship the very best possible chance of working well right from the outset. A little upfront clarity around fees, communication, contacts and turnaround times saves considerable frustration later on, and it establishes a clear standard both sides can be reasonably and fairly held to throughout the relationship. Treat that first conversation as an investment in everything that follows, because the clarity it creates tends to pay for itself many times over in avoided frustration down the line.
Want Direct Access to Senior Financial Advice?
Let's build a relationship you can actually rely on
Fred Michael & Co Ltd offers direct, dedicated access to experienced financial support, including our virtual finance director service.